I did the same way phase 3 did save for voice adjustment, worked aok for me. My cut keeps the establishing shot but cuts the entire elevator scene otherwise so YMMV.
Personally I think folks are overthinking adding this, the film is what is it. You add and watch it or you don’t.
Spitballing ideas into the void here…
I would love to see in S2 of Andor an attempt to assassinate someone like Tarkin, Krennic even Palpatine ala the Wolf’s Lair attempt on Hitler.
I am guessing via the absence of Palpy in most everything that he is this Howard Hughes style paranoid living in seclusion…which really doesn’t make much sense considering he is the Sith Lord of the day.
It would be nice to see a story arc that provides a reason for him to be living the way that he does.
IF he is living like a Howard Hughes paranoid can we at least have a scene of him shuffling around his office with Kleenex boxes for shoes?
David Lynch’s “Lost Highway” is a better example of how to handle the corruption of Anakin Skywalker by the dark side of the force than a mafia movie is.
General Grievous.
Hey Jar Jar Binks was an awful character, can you guys come up with something even worse?
Spread that Pershing stuff throughout the 1st two episodes, would make Mando zipping from world to world feel less like a taxi service and would give the Pershing storyline room to breathe.
I liked it. I like Star Wars and it was goofy and fun and I like goofy and fun Star Wars as much as I like
fascism dissertation Star Wars like we got in Andor.
Git on top of it!
I’m trying!
I can take them both.
What I would really like to see realized at some point is the idea that was developed but not used for The Force Awakens where there’s an Anakin force ghost that is conflicted and has light and dark side elements in conflict and kinda morphs around between these. It was in the making of book and I was always disappointed that it was never developed in ep 8 or 9, I think a really solid scene that would also connect the trilogies would have been to have Anakin’s force ghost have a little chat with Kylo Ren and basically tell him, “not in my name little fascist wannabe.”
The galaxy is allowed to celebrate the destruction of another death star & the death of Palpatine.
I know maybe not in his fanedit but really, ST or not, celebrating what appears at the time to be the defeat of this regime makes absolute sense.
PT General Grevious
OT Ewoks
ST Kylo Ren
I like this a lot, just wish I could figure a way to work it into TESB without it being obvious due to music cues, etc.
What I love about Andor. thinking about the comment immediately above, is that they tried this pre-emptive thing saying “a lot of people are probably not going to like this” and most people love it.
And it deserves all of that love.
(cue “not all of us” in 3…2…1…)
Watch Lost Highway.
Do this.
Change certain characters.
Palpy is Mystery Man
Anakin is Fred Madison
Padme is Renee Madison/Alice Wakefield
Samuel Jackson is Mr Eddy/Dick Laurent
Ewan McGregor is Pete Dayton
I called mine “Forged At Ferrix”
Something that I really like with the edits done him are the blue shields on the docking bays.
Just wanted to say I like your title a lot.
I always try to put a lot of thought into things like that, mine is a two-fer and I called my Ep1 “From a Dusty World to the Stars” becuase I liked the play on Stardust.
I take it that the version posted on the FE network is v1 and not this one aka v2?
Regardless of which version I snagged, this is visually dynamite to look at, a job well done that you should be rightfully proud of.
I’d really like the extended cut of Dead Poets Society to be resurrected on BR.
I had the laser disk ages ago and didn’t convert it when I copied over my laser disks, thought at the time it was a slam dunk for a dvd release. Ha…ah…ha ha …yeah…
Mon Mothma is a MVP in this season and doesn’t get enough credit.
I love pretty much every second of the entire season of this show.
I have it, it’s very much a proof of concept sort of thing. Some of the film added stands out from the main feature, it’s pretty high quality fanfilm stuff but when added to Return of the Jedi a lot of it stands out.
Sorry just checked, maybe not.
I have three that I snagged all around the same time, tagged on my computer as:
ROTJ radical when it irises out to the credits it says edited by Yads. mkv 1:54:28
ROTJ radical re-edit, when it irises out to the credits it says edited by Yads. mkv 1:49:26
ROTJ radical version 2, again irises out edit by Yads. mkv 1:50:08
I think I am confusing this Yads guy with Ziggy, sorry.
The second one is the one that I mentioned that had the fan film stuff worked in with Boba Fett chasing down Han on Endor. It’s the most changed one of the three.
Thanks for sharing it, already snagged one I’ve been looking for some time for.
The motion is to move this convo to DMs is seconded. Kindly get a room.
As much as I like the unknown (to me anyways) actor playing Davo/the Chandrillian gangster whenever I watch those scenes I think oh geez what a missed opportunity to bring Willem Dafoe into the franchise.
I have a friend who lives in Rio and he is amazed at this show, says whoever made it gets things like favelas and really appreciates the representation of that kind of world.
I don’t think it needs trimming at all. I know this is a fanedit site and that is probably herersy, some things are fine just like they are.
And I agree, Mon Mothma is the bomb. I love all of this however I am really enjoying anything that has to do with the ISB and Mon Mothma.